High Info Signals: How to Spot Quality Data in Noisy MarketsMarkets are noisy. Prices move for reasons both rational and irrational, and information arrives in torrents — some of it valuable, some of it distracting, and some actively misleading. Successful traders and analysts don’t just consume more data; they learn to identify high info signals — the pieces of information that reliably improve decision-making. This article explains what high info signals are, how they differ from noise, practical methods to identify them, and how to integrate them into a repeatable trading or analysis process.
What is a high info signal?
A high info signal is a data point or set of observations that meaningfully reduces uncertainty about future price action or the underlying fundamentals of an asset. These signals have predictive value, are robust across different conditions, and can be measured or observed consistently.
Characteristics of high info signals:
- Predictive power: historically correlates with future outcomes.
- Low noise-to-signal ratio: not overwhelmed by random fluctuation.
- Repeatability: can be tested and reproduced across timeframes or instruments.
- Economic or structural rationale: there’s a plausible mechanism linking the signal to market moves.
- Actionability: leads to a clear decision or risk-management change.
Why markets are noisy
Noise comes from many sources:
- Retail chatter, social media hype, and news cycles.
- Short-term liquidity imbalances and algorithmic trading.
- Conflicting reports, revisions, and low-quality data.
- Behavioral biases — herding, overreaction, and anchoring.
- Random shocks and microstructure effects (e.g., bid-ask bounce).
Noise masks true signals and increases the probability of false positives. The goal is to cut through noise and amplify reliable signals.
Types of high info signals
- Fundamental signals
- Earnings surprises, revenue trends, margin expansion, balance-sheet shifts.
- Macro indicators with proven lead/lag relationships (e.g., employment, PMI).
- Market microstructure signals
- Order flow imbalances, volume spikes, changes in bid-ask spread.
- Large, persistent block trades or iceberg orders from informed participants.
- Cross-asset and correlation signals
- Divergences between related instruments (e.g., bond yields vs. bank stocks).
- Commodity price moves impacting equities or currencies.
- Sentiment and positioning metrics
- Institutional positioning (CFTC/Commitments of Traders), fund flows.
- Put-call skew, option open interest shifts indicating hedging or conviction.
- Alternative data
- Satellite imagery, credit card transactions, web traffic, supply-chain telemetry.
- Useful when linked to clear economic activity and available with low latency.
Criteria to evaluate whether a signal is “high info”
Use a simple checklist to screen potential signals:
- Statistical evidence: Does backtesting show a stable edge after transaction costs and slippage?
- Economic rationale: Is there a believable causal pathway connecting the signal to price action?
- Robustness: Does the signal work across different market regimes, timeframes, and sample periods?
- Timeliness: Is the signal available early enough to act on it?
- Parsimony: Is it simple and interpretable, or does it rely on complex, fragile transformations?
- Data quality: Is the data accurate, complete, and free from survivorship or look-ahead bias?
- Cost-effectiveness: Are gains after costs (data, execution, capital) meaningful?
If a signal fails multiple checks, treat it as noise until further evidence exists.
Practical methods to identify high info signals
- Backtest with realistic assumptions
- Use out-of-sample testing, walk-forward analysis, and cross-validation.
- Include realistic transaction costs, market impact, and latency constraints.
- Focus on effect size, not just statistical significance
- Tiny, statistically significant effects often vanish after costs or during regime changes.
- Combine signals orthogonally
- Use uncorrelated signals to reduce overall noise and improve the information ratio.
- Example: combine an order-flow-based short-term signal with a macro fundamental trend.
- Monitor signal decay
- Many strategies degrade as more participants adopt them. Track performance and adapt.
- Use hierarchical modeling and smoothing
- Blend noisy short-term indicators with slower, higher-confidence measures (e.g., Bayesian priors).
- Human-in-the-loop validation
- Analysts can flag regime shifts, structural breaks, or data anomalies that models miss.
- Stress-test across regimes
- Simulate crashes, rallies, and low-volatility environments to see where the signal holds up.
- Evaluate cross-sectional consistency
- A high info signal often shows consistent behavior across similar assets or sectors.
Common high-info signal examples with intuition
- Earnings revision momentum: Analysts consistently raising/ lowering forecasts often precede sustained stock moves because they reflect improving or deteriorating fundamentals.
- Volume-price divergence: When price moves without follow-through volume, it’s likely noise; price moves confirmed by rising volume are more informative.
- Option skew shifts: Rapid changes in implied volatility skew can reveal informational hedging by participants who have superior knowledge or exposure.
- Persistent order flow imbalance: Repetitive buying or selling pressure from large, presumably informed traders signals a probable directional move.
- Supply-chain telemetry (e.g., shipping, factory throughput): Directly ties to production and revenues and can pre-date reported earnings.
Common pitfalls and how to avoid them
- Overfitting: Avoid overly complex models that fit historical noise. Use simpler models and penalize complexity.
- Data mining bias: If you search for patterns exhaustively without adjustment, some will be spurious. Correct for multiple testing.
- Survivorship bias: Use full historical datasets including delisted or failed instruments.
- Look-ahead bias: Ensure only information available at the decision time is used.
- Confirmation bias: Seek disconfirming evidence; try to falsify hypotheses, not only confirm them.
- Ignoring regime shifts: A signal that worked during a bull market may fail during a liquidity crisis. Reassess periodically.
Building a workflow to capture high-info signals
- Idea generation: Collect candidate signals from research, alternative data providers, and market intuition.
- Pre-screening: Apply the evaluation checklist (economics, data quality, timeliness).
- Backtesting & validation: Robust statistical testing, walk-forward and out-of-sample checks.
- Risk & cost analysis: Evaluate execution feasibility, capital needs, and worst-case scenarios.
- Deployment with monitoring: Implement small-scale live tests; monitor performance and decay.
- Governance & iteration: Periodically review signals, decommission failing ones, and add new candidates.
Example: short-term trade using order-flow + volume confirmation
- Signal components:
- Order-flow imbalance: sustained buy-initiated trades at the ask over 15 minutes.
- Volume confirmation: 30% higher-than-average 15-minute volume.
- Volatility filter: ignore when intraday realized volatility exceeds a threshold (to avoid erratic sessions).
- Process:
- Pre-screen instruments with sufficient liquidity.
- Trigger entry only when both order-flow imbalance and volume confirmation occur.
- Place tight initial stop-loss referencing recent microstructure levels; scale out as movement confirms.
- Record outcomes and retrain thresholds monthly.
This combines orthogonal high-info elements (microstructure and volume) and enforces risk controls to avoid overfitting.
Measuring success: metrics that matter
- Information ratio (excess return per unit tracking error)
- Hit-rate and average return per win vs loss
- Profit factor and Sharpe ratio after costs
- Max drawdown and time-to-recovery
- Execution slippage and realized market impact
- Decay rate of the edge over time
Track both statistical and economic performance — a strategy may be statistically significant but economically marginal once costs are included.
Final thoughts
High info signals are the difference between noise-driven trading and disciplined decision-making. They require a marriage of statistical rigor, economic reasoning, and operational discipline. No signal is permanent; constant validation, adaptation, and honest performance assessment are the habits that separate durable edges from fleeting patterns.
Leave a Reply